How IfOnly Works


Discover thousands of experiences with top luminaries for any occasions.


Connect directly with our luminaries to book your experiences on your own schedules.


Embark on your adventure and leave us a review of your experience.

Welcome ,

We look forward to delighting you.


Thank you!

Please check your inbox for your welcome email and your unique promo code

Sorry, your email does not match our records. Please use your Amex Concierge email to sign-up for an IfOnly Concierge account.

Your email is already in our system, but has not yet been verified. We previously sent you an email - finish setting up your account by pressing the “CONFIRM EMAIL” button.

If you need us to send you another email, please press below.

If you do not receive an email within 5 minutes, please call 415-376-4646 and our Guest Experiences Team will assist you.


concierge-img Elizabeth and our concierge team would be delighted to assist you.


(415) 376-4640
Monday through Friday, 9am–6pm PT

Send a Message


How to buy gift

Billy Joel After Party with Shake Rattle & Roll Dueling Pianos: In New York, New York

Mark Weiser

Benefiting Musicians On Call

Billy Joel After Party with Shake Rattle & Roll Dueling Pianos

Keep the rock 'n' roll, piano party going right after Billy Joel's Madison Square Garden concert next door at Shake Rattle & Roll Dueling Pianos.

New York, New York

3 hours

Past Event


Share this with your friends!

Click a button below and share this with your friends.

Share this through Email

Import addresses through webmail


Share this through Email


Retrieving Your Contacts


Choose from Your Contacts
Select All


    The Experience

    The long running, sold out, all request, rock 'n' roll party, that has been playing New York City on Saturday nights for more than six years, is now bringing the fun to the house that Billy Joel built. Following his sold-out concert at Madison Square Garden, join us right next door at The Pennsy, for our sing along, dance along, laugh along, drink along Dueling Pianos show.

    Your preferred seating is waiting for you, with table-side waitress service, and all your favorite songs from Billy to Bon Jovi, Britney Spears to Bruno Mars, and  so much more. Come see why TimeOut New York calls Shake Rattle & Roll one of the things to do in NYC. 


    • Located at the Pennsey, right next door to Madison Square Garden
    • Awesome food from the likes of Mario Batali and others. 
    • Music, comedy, dancing, and more. 
    • All request playlist with over 5000 songs to choose from
    • Great for birthdays, bachelorettes, and groups of 2, 20, or 200
    • The perfect end to your night at Madison Square Garden, or if you just wanna pretend you were there

    read fine print

    Request A Quote


    We are sorry.

    The requested quantity is not available.

    Would you like to be notified when more becomes available?

    Add to waitlist


    You have been added to our waitlist!

    • So glad you like this! If we have it or a similar item again, we will be sure to let you know.

      So we are sure to reach you, please enter or verify your contact information below:

    • Submit

    This item has been added to your Wishlist!

    Local, Find amazing experiences in your city
    Find amazing experiences in your city
    Once-in-a-Lifetime Experiences, For over the top occasions.
    Once-in-a-Lifetime Experiences
    For over the top occasions.
    Charity Auctions and Sweepstakes, Bid and give back
    Charity Auctions and Sweepstakes
    Bid and give back

    How can we help you?

    We'll keep you updated on new experiences in your city.

    Sign Up

    By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use

    Enter the address where you would like this experience to happen



    Could not find your address. Please enter the address again and make sure that it is correct.

    Original address:






    Back to Cart

    Use Different Card

    Or use valid card in Masterpass

    Exclusive to



    This product is not available in the language you've selected, if you choose to continue with the language change you will be re-directed to the homepage. Would you still like to change languages?

    You will not be able to increase the number of days if you change this. Are you sure you want to proceed?



    Looks like you're trying to switch languages!

    We can only checkout in one language and currency. If you switch languages now, the item in your cart will not appear. Please checkout now to avoid losing your selection.

    To add this to your cart, please sign into your Priceless account or continue as a guest.

    continue as a guest

    Unsupported Browser

    Google Chrome for iOS does not support this feature.

    Please use Safari and try again or